A method statement is rarely returned for what it says. It is returned for what it leaves out, and on heavy steel work the reviewer leaves the same comments on almost every submission.
We write ours to answer those comments before they are made. The list below comes from the review forms on two bridge jobs, comment by comment.
The first return lists what is missing
On the 15 July Martyrs Bridge (Bosphorus Bridge), the crack repair procedure for the orthotropic deck was the engineer's, and our crews carried out the repairs. That did not shorten the review. In March 2014 the engineer returned the Type 1 method revision marked "Amend and Resubmit" and listed the documents still missing, including material certificates, a survey giving the location and dimensions of every crack, shop drawings, the welding procedure specification, electrode certificates, a detailed quality control plan and the magnetic particle test method.
It also listed four steps the procedure had skipped. The rib was to be tack-welded to the diaphragm at four points before re-welding. Every re-weld was to be magnetic particle tested 24 hours after welding, and the reinforcing plate fitted only after those tests. The paint under the plate was to be removed for steel-to-steel contact, and on site we were asked to take it back to bright steel.
The Type 2, 3 and 4 repairs went the same way. The first issue came back in April 2014, again marked "Amend and Resubmit", with a request to resubmit in English and Turkish. That submission had asked for approval to resume the repairs. The procedure that was finally approved was revision 03.
On the 1915 Çanakkale Bridge, our method statement for dismantling the temporary structures on the tower tops and in the anchor blocks was issued three times in August 2022 alone, revisions 00 to 02, and submitted again in September and November while the works ran.
A lifting point is checked on site, not on the drawing
The second comment on the Çanakkale review was the one that mattered most: every lifting point had to be checked on the drawings and on site, and the lifting equipment and lugs defined from what was found. After the site inspection, the reviewer asked for the points to be evaluated again.
The comments that followed came from the same concern. Anything attached for lifting or lowering had to be shown. A sling could not stand in for a lug, because a sharp corner cuts it and the connection reduces its capacity. The weight of every frame and platform was required, and for the winches, whether the figure included the wire.
So each piece got its own lift plan. For the first tower-top bent block, the plan gives a net load of 5.50 tonnes, 7.18 tonnes gross once the hook block and gear are added, and a safe working load of 20 tonnes at a 25 m radius on the tower-top crane. A note on the plan says the load is checked again against the crane's actual position on site.
Sequence follows access
The reviewer asked for the dismantling sequence to be revised and tied it to the date the hoist would come down: the south side was reached from the hoist, so it had to stay until the hoist was gone. Three weeks later the sequence changed again, and the winches and their supports came first.
Another comment said the method looked like the earlier temporary works plan, carried over without development. An inherited plan records how the steel went up under someone else's method. It does not show how the steel comes down with the cranes, access and dates of the dismantling job, so we re-engineer it rather than copy it.
The fallback is written before the bolt seizes
The reviewer asked what we would do if a bolt would not release with the torque machine. The answer went into the method statement, and the list of equipment it needed, jacks included, was sent with the next revision.
Every other open question was handled the same way. The manpower plan was broken down by activity, and the equipment plan by working location: both towers, both anchorages and the dry dock. Lifting equipment certificates and mobile crane details were added. The reviewer asked whether we would work nights; after discussion, two shifts were set for all activities.
A method statement that says "if required" invites the next comment. One that names the fallback, the equipment and who brings it closes the item.
Every lowered piece has a landing place
Pieces lowered from the tower tops passed through a gap in the deck. The reviewer asked how that step would be controlled, and we placed riggers around the gap during lifting and lowering. The exact landing location of every piece had to be planned and shown. Unloading at the dry dock needed its own plan, with the lifting equipment ready there and the crane capacity checked against site conditions. Those plans went in as appendices.
The permanent structure needed an answer too. Cutting work on one tower-top block had to be evaluated under the project QA/QC procedure for testing and repair. The reviewer asked how the permanent structure would be protected, and our answer was to cover it. Lowering could also affect a traffic lane that was open.
A separate safety review of the same method returned seventeen comments. Again and again they asked three things of each task: how the crew reaches it, how material is kept from falling, and how a worker is rescued.
What we do not do
Design responsibility for the permanent structure stays with its designer. We design our own temporary works and prepare detail drawings to the designer's scheme. We do not approve our own method; approval belongs to the engineer or the designer. Non-destructive testing is carried out by third parties, and third-party inspection of lifting equipment is not part of our scope.
Before you submit
A survey of the existing condition: crack locations and sizes, lifting points checked on site.
A lift plan for each piece: weight including rigging, crane radius, safe working load.
A sequence tied to access and to the dates that control it.
The fallback for connections that will not release, with its equipment.
A landing place for every lowered piece, and protection for the permanent structure.
The documents the reviewer will ask for anyway: certificates, welding procedures, the quality control plan and the test method.
Access, falling-object protection and rescue for every task.
The record
On the 1915 Çanakkale Bridge, the main contractor's acceptance team inspected the works, and the taking-over certificate was issued on 30 January 2023 with no missing items. On the Bosphorus Bridge, the final acceptance certificate was signed in July 2017, recording no obstacle to acceptance.
Send us the drawings and the site constraints. We will set out how we would erect or remove the steel, and what our method statement would cover.
